Chanel Raffinement Vs. Sable-Emouvant Duo - Swatches

I was asked for a comparison between the Chanel Sable-Emouvant eyeshadow duo - part of Chanel's Summer 2012 makeup collection - and the newly launched Chanel eyeshadow quad Raffinement.  Both have a dark brown shade and a pale peach/beige highlighter shade included.  The darker shade in Sable-Emouvant has fine copper shimmer in it and has warm undertones to it while Raffinement has a cooler dark brown matte shade.  The highlighter in Raffinement leans a bit ashy on me with it's cooler undertones.  Here's a look at some side-by-side photos and swatches:

Chanel Eyeshadow Quad Raffinement Sable Emouvant Duo Swatches Comparisons Indian Beauty Makeup Blog Neutral Brown Palettes
Chanel Eyeshadow Quad Raffinement Sable Emouvant Duo Swatches Comparisons Indian Beauty Makeup Blog Neutral Brown Palettes
Chanel Eyeshadow Quad Raffinement Sable Emouvant Duo Swatches Comparisons Indian Beauty Makeup Blog Neutral Brown Palettes

I love both Raffinement and Sable-Emouvant, and I do find them quite different - sure they both have browns, but I won't mistake one for the other!  Between the two, if I really, absolutely, just had to choose one, I would probably pick Chanel's Sable-Emouvant - I like the warmer undertones in the brown just a teeny bit more.  The beige shade also looks much better on my skin than the highlighter shade in Raffinement.  What would you pick - Raffinment or Sable-Emouvant?